Blog

  • City Camp: Civic (Low-)Tech

    Slide from Beta NYC opening remarks, Hunter College Auditorium. September 19, 2026. Quote by A. Philip Randolph, activist and director of 1963 March on Washington. Photo by EF.
    Civic Low-Tech session description on the schedule board. Full session schedule available on Beta NYC Drive. Photo by EF.

    Session Details:

    • A group discussion exploring low-tech solutions for civic engagement and sharing community information.
    • 1 hour discussion with roughly 20 participants
    • Full notes available thanks to our volunteer note taker
    • Main topics/exerpts:
      • What counts as “low-tech”? Old technology? Low barrier to entry? Could “high-tech” be apart of the solution?
      • Audience and geography determines best method of communication
      • What causes a source to be trusted? Are local sources more trusted?
      • Scale of outreach. Smaller, local outreach may justify higher cost, higher impact methods.
      • Returning control to communities, to set the agenda, to engage in sense-making
      • Is the spectacle of tech obscuring the human connections?
      • Where has innovation genuinely helped? When has it been a distraction? What is most effective for meeting people where they are at.
      • Who gets left behind with different technology strategies/uses?
      • Where do we engage: Online? Via tech? In public spaces?
    • Technologies/methods referenced:
      • Davis Sq Message Board
      • Bulletin Boards
      • Flyers
      • Door knocking, perhaps assisted by high tech apps/GIS
      • Hyperlocal digital newsletters/Substacks, advertised via physical flyers in local spaces
      • Phone calls
      • Local radio stations
      • Community events, block parties
      • Bagels and hand written fliers, used to attract tenants to gather and talk

    Thank you to all who participated and indulged in this conversation!

  • Davis Square Message Board

    A historic survey of community messages posted to the digital sign located on the Middlesex Federal Savings Bank in Davis Square.

    “WELCOMES YOU TO DAVIS SQUARE!!” – March 2016

    Davis Square is a busy urban square that is home to a MBTA Redline and bus station, Community Bike path, commercial spaces, Tufts, and dense residential neighborhoods.

    Digital sign features:

    • Low tech
    • Provides information directly to the public and local community
    • Supports a wide variety of local needs
    Map of Davis Square, STAR indicates location of the digital sign. Source: Open Street Map

    “Boston Warriors basketball holding tryouts” – Sep 2013

    “showcase work at Charles River Arts Program” – Aug 2011

    “Boston 2024 rethinking cycling infrastructure” – June 2015

    “Havurat Shalom Open House on Saturday” – Sep 2014

    “Taste of Somerville Rescheduled for Wednesday” – June 2018

    “Solarize Somerville: More info at” – Sep 2016

    “march to defend democracy in Boston, Worcester” – Nov 2020

    “Free Covid-19 testing for Somerville residents” – Nov 2020

    Source: Scenes captured from Google Streetview footage from 2011 – 2020

  • Project engagement on Transit app

    Transit app highlights active DDOT Priority Projects and links directly to them.

    Transit app connects users to engagement opportunities and offers free outreach to users for projects and proposals that it supports.

    Sources:

  • DC DDOT Yard Sign Engagement

    • Photo by author

    QR Code: Grant Circle Safety Improvement Project website

    Source: DDOT Project Website

    Details:

    • Signs placed through out project area
    • Notifies all users in the area, not just residents
    • Notifies public of upcoming and ongoing work being done in the area.
    • Easily connects users to additional info via QR code
    • Enduring notification, not a one time notice (like a flyer or door knock)
    • Relatively cheap signage materials, easy to scale

    Seems to only be to notify the public of construction impacts and plans. Unclear if signs were in place during or used for the earlier public engagement/comment period.

  • Play Squirrel Trail

    An alley based choose your own adventure;

    Available on Itch.io: https://loud-attic.itch.io/squirrel-trail

  • Philadelphia Water Shed

    The Watershed, in Germantown. Photo by EF, October 2025. Via Indego Bike Share

    Notes:

    • Public outreach in flood prone community (Germantown, Philadelphia)
    • Provides resources and info on local risk (interior, stormwater flooding)
    • Long term installation with regular hours
      • (not that regular, though, was closed when I visited 😔)
    • Hosts events, community gatherings
    • Hosts artists
    • Depository for community expereinces with flooding
    • Partnership with the Philadelphia Water Department (PWD), Mural Arts Philadelphia, and the Academy of Natural Sciences of Drexel University
    • Opened in 2024

    “The WaterShed, open weekly at 5300 Wayne Avenue, serves as a resource center and place of exchange. We offer flood preparedness resources, educational programming, community science initiatives, collaborative climate resilience planning projects, and a resident artist program. By combining art, science, and advocacy, the WaterShed helps residents better understand and address flooding at both grassroots and institutional levels, while ensuring that the experiences and expertise of Germantown residents directly inform how the city responds to a climate challenge more than 150 years in the making.”

    Project Director

    Ryan Strand Greenberg

    WaterShed Storefront Manager

    Deneene Brockington

    Science Team

    Alexis Schulman, Winn Costantini, Akilah Chatman, Zoe Kerrich

    Climate Resilience Planning Partners

    Germantown Residents for Economic Alternatives Togther

    2026 Resident Artists

    Ingrid Raphael, Li Sumpter, Nancy Agati, Rebecca Schultz

    Founding Co-Curator

    Phoebe Bachman

    Community Leads

    Maura Jarvis, Reverend Williams

    Founding Resident Artists

    Naomieh Jovin, Kaitlin Pomerantz

    Founding Project Manager

    Keisha Whatley

    Project Partners

    the Academy of Natural Sciences, Mural Arts Philadelphia, the Philadelphia Water Department, Awbury Arboretum

    Sponsors

    Philadelphia Water Department, William Penn Foundation

    Sources: